In his outstanding article, Cdr Allan Rodrigues (Retd.) recounted the incident of a young Squadron Cadet Captain “snitching” on his coursemates in the National Defence Academy (NDA). The revelation that the SCC was none other than 2nd Lt Arun Khetrapal, who went on to win India’s highest wartime gallantry awards, would undoubtedly have made the story all the more significant to a reader. Another interesting anecdote associated with Khetarpal’s heroism on the battlefield is the story of a retired Pakistani Army officer Brigadier Khwaja Mohammad Naser (Retd.) who sought out 2nd Lt Khetrapal’s father several decades later when he was visiting Pakistan in 2001. Naser was the Squadron Commander in 1971 of 13 Lancers, the Pakistan regiment that fought Arun’s Poona Horse at the battle of Basantar on 16 Dec 1971, the penultimate day of the war. Naser’s regiment lost a lot of tanks and Arun’s and his own tank fired on each other in a final volley. Arun died; Naser lived. Arun’s father, Brigadier Khetrapal heard this story first-hand from Naser while visiting his ancestral town, which was now in Pakistan. It was thoughtful and chivalrous of Naser, an erstwhile enemy tank commander who not only recounted young Khetrapal’s bravery but also admitted to a father that it was he who had killed his son. The NDA parade ground is befittingly named after 2nd Lt Arun Khetrapal and is a hallowed place. Every cadet considers it a great honour to pass out of its Quarterdeck. In making the connections between the moral courage Khetrapal demonstrated as an SCC in his final term at NDA and the valour he showed on the battlefield a year and a half later, Cdr Rodrigues has done a great service by deciding to write about this incident and drawing out lessons in ethics and leadership for the audience. It must not have been easy penning that piece, considering his own sense of guilt and remorse associated with this incident.

In his editorial of the same issue, the Editor-in-Chief posed difficult questions that perhaps have no clear-cut answers. He challenged us to think through these questions: “How would 2nd Lt Arun Khetrapal have been perceived by his peers and juniors had he not fallen on the battlefield? Or, if he did not have an opportunity to lead his band of men into battle and acquit himself the way he did. Would he have been branded a snitch all his life?” Considering that I admired and revered Arun Khetrapal right from my time as a cadet, I might err in objectively answering the editors’ questions. Notwithstanding this, I believe the question deserves to be examined, for it drives to the heart of the differences between honour, ethics and integrity and how these are perceived. Unfortunately, we often use these words interchangeably when discussing ethical behaviour and they are easily misunderstood.

Ethics refers to a person’s set of moral principles. An ethical person behaves justly, fairly and rightly. He conducts himself by a moral framework that he has imbibed and developed. A person can be ethical by himself, whereas honour requires a community. One cannot be honourable by oneself; to be honourable, one needs to act in accordance with the moral principles of the community. Loyalty is a cherished value of any community, for it keeps the community together. Therefore, any perceived disloyalty is considered dishonourable and is likely to invite the collective wrath of the community as it happened on an eventful night in front of the Foxtrot Squadron. The actions of the young SCC that day reflected that he was an ethical person. But the aftermath of the reporting reflected that cadets as a community had incorrectly identified loyalty worked only sideways towards ones coursemates rather than your juniors and seniors. The cadets who chose to go outside Foxtrot squadron on that night thought what they were doing was “honourable,” whilst Khetrapal’s reporting his coursemates was considered dishonourable. The author notes that Khetrapal was in all likelihood, fully aware of the consequences of his breaking the “omerta,” the Mafiosi code of silence. That he chose to go ahead with it, brings out his impeccable sense of integrity.

What, then, is integrity? In an excellent essay on integrity, David Luban notes that integrity is so much more than honesty alone. Integrity is an inner consistency between deed and principle. Was Arun Khetrapal the only one amongst his peers to notice the late-night escapades and their deleterious effect on the junior cadets? Perhaps not, but Khetrapal alone chose to take on the burden of reporting the incident and the concomitant ignominy that followed. What then would have happened had the war of ’71 itself not happened? One hopes that, like the author, Khetrapal’s peers and juniors would have realised that the standard by which they judged Arun Khetrapal was downright incorrect and a myopic view of loyalty and of ‘course spirit.’

The concept of moral standards of a community is fluid and abstract; therefore, professional organisations, including the Navy, have expended considerable effort in unequivocally laying down the values and moral standards of behaviour considered correct. Perhaps, a few of his peers affected by his actions may never forgive him, but Arun Khetrapal would have gone on to win the trust and loyalty of his men. As the author notes, Arun Khetrapal was a military leader in the truest sense of the Chetwode code even before he reached Basantar with his tanks.

In separate “Both Watches” responses to my earlier article, “Appetising Wrong or an Insipid Right,” both Cdr Allan Rodrigues (Retd.) and Lt Col MD Saunders (Retd.) of the Australian Army pointed out that incorrect inferences seem to have been drawn from the incident of a SEAL team which got compromised by goatherds during a mission in Afghanistan. Cdr Rodrigues highlighted the danger of a cowardly soldier using ethics as a cover to shirk his responsibility of fighting. MD Saunders pointed out that the causality of the incident seems to have been incorrectly identified, in as much that the decision of letting go of the goatherds didn’t result in the SEAL team taking casualties, but in deciding to go ahead with the mission. Both writers make valid points. It appears the article advocates forsaking a mission if the course of action is prima facie unethical. In a hypothetical scenario, what if Lt Murphy had two clear-cut choices (a): release the goatherds leading to a sure-shot killing of his team or (b) kill the goatherds and complete the mission or escape alive from the situation? Might Murphy still have chosen not to take the lives of the goatherds? A situation where the consequences of our actions are clear simplifies decision-making as we could then rely on moral relativism and tend to choose the lesser of the two evils.

In his magnum opus of a novel, Once an Eagle, Anton Myrer contrasts the career of two officers, Sam Damon and Courtney Massengale. Sam Damon, an epitome of honour, kills a wounded man as they storm a German position in the First World War. Whilst he is racked with guilt, he concedes that it was necessary to capture the building and save his platoon. Would battle with its accompanying fog of uncertainty allow us the luxury of foreseeing the consequences of our actions? Or, use moral relativism as a tool and choose the lesser of two evils. The incident of Lt Murphy was used to highlight that sometimes the consequences of doing what we believe is ethically correct, could have disastrous consequences. That said, the elucidation and clarification provided by both commentators were necessary and added much value to this magazine’s discussions on ethics. RAdm Arjun Dev Nair (Monsoon 2022, pp 20-33) also highlighted how a correct decision not to launch a helicopter for Search and Rescue could be reprehensible for one’s belief system and the community at large. Incidents such as this are par for the course for every leader at sea. Moral courage is built and developed over time; the importance of evaluating tactical and operational issues via ethical lenses by military leaders ought never to be understated. Arun Khetrapal understood this better than many others even before he was tested on the battlefield.