A series of articles in the Despatch have brought to the fore some difficult but essential conversations around morals and ethics. I make my debut in taking that conversation forward via some personal experiences, triggered by Cdr Allan Rodrigues’ insightful and moving story of his own days with 2Lt Arun Khetarpal, PVC (Posthumous) as the antagonist turned protagonist, and the wrenching and remorse that he felt about his and almost everyone else’s initial reactions.
Upon reading this and Adm Arun Prakash’s furtherance of the discussion, I was initially hesitant to weigh-in on the subject; I can neither match the eloquence of their pens nor do I have any combat experience. On second thoughts, the same must be true for most contributors and readers today. It took Cdr Rodrigues 51 years to share his anecdote; I turn 54 this winter and it may be apt and possibly cathartic to write about my own tryst with ethics, morals and integrity.
Exactly 28 years ago, a Chetak (Alouette) helicopter tasked for a routine training sortie off Kochi crashed at sea, killing a trainee Air Crewman Diver (ACM (D)). One of the pilots was a young lieutenant of the recent batch of the naval helicopter training school. He might have thought he had all the markings of a successful naval officer. The self-imposed pressure of the final stage of an ACM (D) conversion course meant flying several sorties each day. On the fateful morning, despite a safety boat not being available, the crew and authorising officer decided to go ahead with the sortie “in good faith” using any opportune vessel. This was the first of many fatal errors. While hovering over a local fishing boat entering Kochi channel, the helicopter went out of control and crashed into the sea. The survivors gave their statements to the station flight safety officer soon after rescue, and a Board of Inquiry (BoI) was convened.
By all indications, it seemed to be some technical failure. Nonetheless, the scuttlebutt was spreading that the crew might have been doing some unauthorised flying (“picking up fish”), which factually they were not. There was also a concern that the BoI might flag the danger of bird activity above a fishing boat entering harbour, laden with catch. A senior supervisor suggested, again “in good faith,” that the young pilot and his senior co-pilot may like to reverse the direction of the boat (leaving the harbour as against entering the harbour) as “it won’t matter much, but will quell the ‘picking up fish’ angle.” Call it a “smart act,” “manage” or what you will, but the crew went along, slowly entering the unholy arena of false affidavits and cross-questioning, until finally the young pilot broke ranks and made a voluntary confession to the board.
That pilot was me, stunned by an accident at the infancy of my flying career and beholden to the “good faith” guidance of seniors. I was no self-realised Gandhi; nor were there any people of the mettle of SCC Arun Khetarpal around. Lines blurred and, at a difficult juncture where my reputation and career were at stake, the easier wrong prevailed over the harder right.
As richly deserved, I was court-martialled, sentenced and punished at the young age of 26 - about four years more than Arun Khetrapal’s lifespan. My defence counsel, a fellow aviator who went to great lengths to defend young KPS, wept when the verdict was pronounced – not because I was wholly innocent or pristine – but because not one senior around me had redeemed himself with honour or integrity in the entire saga, leaving me with a severe sentence. Amidst all this, sadly, the ACM(D)’s family had lost a breadwinner forever. My career was all but sunk, but, more importantly, I had fallen in my own eyes.
A year later when my senior co-pilot was up for court-martial, the prosecution suggested that I “help out” the fellow accused by withholding some information “since the case is over and you have already paid the price for both.” I refused, stood my ground, spoke truth to power and walked out of the court martial hall with head held high, salvaging whatever was left of my reputation and credibility.
Mark these words for this is usually the ultimate price one pays to be on the wrong side of professional and personal ethics and integrity. There is no prosthetic for an amputated soul (Recall actor Al Pacino as Lt Col Frank Slade, in the 1992 Hollywood movie Scent of a Woman.)
That I eventually made a full comeback, qualified as an experimental test pilot, rose to the rank of Commander and was even “wet-listed” for a sea appointment thirteen years later bears testimony to the fact that our system has adequate bandwidth for ‘errors of commission’ and lifelines for the good. But my bruises are lifelong; I carry the burden of shame and pangs of conscience to this day. The accident was pivotal in my early, voluntary exit from the Navy, even when I believed the Personnel Branch had great plans for me. I knew it would be a lifelong exercise in futility trying to exorcise ghosts from the past. To date, I do not regret my decision to forego a career that might have led to promotion(s) and retired while I was still on the “winning” side.
Our officers, men and now increasingly women, are our strength and brand ambassadors as well. As always, they are highly impressionable. Do they wonder, seeing themselves and the environment if the ‘service before self’ moral and professional code that guided Khetrapal still underpins the conduct of a vast majority of the men senior to them in uniform and outside of it? Are we seeing a slow erosion of values in the military as to go almost unnoticed?
As cadets from the experimental first course of 10+2 (X), Naval Academy, Goa, we did not have any great academy legacy, customs or traditions to fall back on. I can say with candour that I have been witness to almost all the ills that have been raised by commentators on the subject: winning at all costs; omerta applied to wrongdoings by coursemates; toxic leadership; plagiarism, breaking the honour code. We must have seen all this and more. Therefore, I do not quite share one author’s buoyant optimism (Training for Ethics, Spring 2022) that ‘all is well’ or that we have all the tools needed to fix it. If brick-and-mortar establishments like CELABS or modern infrastructure like that of INA could breathe morals and ethics into young cadets and junior officers, we would not be discussing these issues on these pages and elsewhere within smaller groups in the Service.
That INDES has opened this subject up for discussion fills me with the hope that we will see better days. On a larger canvas, we should be able to individually look ourselves in the eye in the mirror and sort ourselves out to derive the benefit of collective strength and fortitude underlined by moral rectitude across the Service. To my mind, the only real way is to lead by example; indeed, it always has been so. Initial years are vital as Adm Arun Prakash explains in Mighty Oaks from Little Acorns Grow in his commentary in an earlier Both Watches.
The article, An Appetising Wrong or an Insipid Right (Winter 2021), by Lt Cdr Rajiv Lochan and the thought-provoking commentary it has triggered, spawns hope that we do recognise that there are ethical problems and that talk and walk have to converge in the woods of real-life issues in peacetime affairs of our Service and in war. What is also a parallel reality is that for every self-entitled senior, there are ten examples of 24-carat leaders amidst us. We need not go into specific examples here, but I wrote about one such instance elsewhere and here is the link for it: https://kaypius.com/2019/04/26/service-before-self-or-self-service/. We have managed to keep the peace for long. That, however, also means that we have not really been put to the test in a shooting war for over five decades. But, that is what the Service needs to be ready for at short notice, and for which professionalism reinforced by the moral and physical courage exemplified by Arun Khetrapal is fundamental. The slew of changes brought about at a frenetic pace (Agniveers, women in NDA, female combatant PBORs, etc.) makes it all the more important that we mainstream the discourse around leadership, professional and personal ethics and morals. If done right, it will be deeply effective; if we window-dress our lives, expect little to change. For this, leaders ought to breathe, practice and live what is preached. The world is more transparent than you may like!


